
Conflict is always present between stakeholders in any project, but there are different conflict levels that require an appropriate response. Not all conflicts should be treated the same, and as a project manager, understanding the conflict level helps you choose the right response before a disagreement damages your team or your project.
- The 5 conflict levels: Problem to Solve, Disagreement, Contest, Crusade and World War. Speed Leas created the model, and Lyssa Adkins adapted it for agile project teams.
- Language is the tell: facts at level 1, vague and guarded words at level 2, “always” and “never” at level 3, ideology at level 4 and silence at level 5.
- Step back or step in: teams can often settle conflict up to level 3 on their own. Project managers step in at level 4 and separate people at level 5.
- Why it matters: people now spend more than 4 hours a week dealing with workplace conflict, up from 2.8 hours in 2008.
According to conflict expert Speed Leas, whose five-level model Lyssa Adkins adapted for agile project teams, conflict tends to escalate in a predictable pattern. An unresolved conflict starts with a problem that needs to be solved and can escalate to a world war, which is the worst-case scenario.
Level 1: Problem to Solve

One sign of a level 1 conflict is that language is used with good intentions and stays constructive. People are motivated to share information and to collaborate with someone else to fix the problem.
Another sign of level 1 conflict is when facts are used to back up an argument. A team at this level of conflict will still be relatively optimistic and capable of moving through the conflict. It is closest to the constructive task conflict found in high-performing teams.
Signs
- Language is generally open-hearted and constructive.
- People use facts to back up the argument.
Response Options
- Collaboration: Look for a win-win situation.
- Consensus: Look for a solution everyone can agree on.
Real-life example
Pixar’s Braintrust keeps conflict at level 1
Pixar built a standing group of experienced storytellers, the Braintrust, to give directors blunt notes on films in progress. The group has no authority to force changes, so the conversation stays about the problem on screen, not about who wins. Director and critics share one goal: a better film. Catmull writes that even hits such as Toy Story and Up started out weak and got better through these notes.
From the field
“Candor isn’t cruel. It does not destroy.”
Ed Catmull, Pixar co-founder, in Creativity, Inc. (source)
By the numbers
- 81%of U.S. workers have seen positive outcomes from workplace conflict
- 41%say conflict left them with a better understanding of others
Source: EHS Today, on the CPP workplace conflict study, 2008
Level 2: Disagreement

While level 2 isn’t considered a hostile level of conflict, it is the point where people start building walls. A sign of a disagreement is language that is geared more towards protecting oneself.
The premise is that protecting oneself becomes as important as collaborating with others. The language in a level 2 conflict is more guarded and a lot less direct, so it can be open to interpretation. In a project team, this shows up when members distance themselves or take a position they believe will help in a future compromise. Underlying conflicts may emerge and build into level 3.
Signs
- Language is self-protective.
Response Options
- Support: Empower the team to resolve disagreements themselves.
- Safety: Use collaboration games to reinforce team shared values.
Real-life example
NASA’s Columbia engineers kept their doubts to themselves
In 2003, several engineers wanted satellite photos of the shuttle Columbia after foam struck its wing. They never raised the request at the key meetings, and the head of the mission management team later said she had only heard a vague report of it. Accident investigators later blamed a culture where people protected themselves instead of speaking up. That is level 2 behavior: no hostility, just guarded silence.
Source: The Seattle Times, July 2003
From the field
“I was too low down here in the organization and she’s way up here.”
Rodney Rocha, NASA structural engineer, to ABC News, 2003 (source)
By the numbers
- 4.34 hrsper week spent dealing with conflict at work, on average
- 36%deal with conflict often or all the time, up from 29% in 2008
Level 3: Contest

Level 3 conflict is when factions begin to emerge. Misunderstandings and power politics make an appearance, and people begin to align themselves by picking a side. A sign of a contest is distorted language, where people make presumptions and overgeneralize.
The language in a level 3 conflict turns personal, with the goal of winning the conflict instead of resolving it. Some examples may be “He always forgets to turn off the system before he leaves our meetings” or “You always interrupt me when I have some input to share”. Team members also view themselves as well-meaning, while seeing the other side as less well-meaning.
Signs
- Language is distorted, with presumptions and overgeneralization.
Response Options
- Accommodate: Yield to others’ viewpoints when the relationship is more important than the issue.
- Negotiate: If an issue is “dividable”, then negotiation can work.
- Get Factual: Gather data on an issue to get facts.
Real-life example
Microsoft’s stack ranking turned colleagues into rivals
For years, Microsoft’s review system forced every team to rate a fixed share of people as top, average or poor performers. A 2012 Vanity Fair investigation reported that every current and former employee interviewed named it as the most destructive process inside the company. Teammates competed to win their rankings instead of solving problems together, a textbook level 3 contest. Microsoft dropped the system in 2013.
Source: Computerworld, on Vanity Fair’s Microsoft’s Lost Decade
From the field
“…employees focusing on competing with each other…”
A former Microsoft software developer, to Vanity Fair, 2012 (source)
By the numbers
- 2.8 hrsa week that U.S. employees spent dealing with conflict in 2008
- $359Bin paid hours spent on conflict by U.S. companies in 2008
Source: EHS Today, on the CPP workplace conflict study, 2008
Level 4: Crusade

The signs of a crusade are when conflict becomes polarized and ideological. The focus now shifts to protecting one’s own group. At this level, resolving the situation is no longer enough. Team members believe the others cannot change, and they may see the only option as removing the others from the team or leaving it themselves.
The factions that were created in level 3 become more solid and see the other side as the enemy. Everyone outside their faction is attacked for who they are affiliated with, not for the ideas they have. Groups also see themselves as righteous.
Signs
- The conflict becomes ideological and polarized.
Response Options
- Diplomacy: Be a facilitator between the two groups, as direct communication has broken down.
- De-escalate: Try to lower the level of conflict.
Real-life example
OpenAI’s boardroom split became a crusade in one weekend
In November 2023, OpenAI’s board fired chief executive Sam Altman. Within three days, most employees had signed a letter saying they could not work with the board and threatening to follow Altman to Microsoft. Two camps saw each other as unfit to lead, and fixing the original issue no longer mattered. Altman returned within days and most of the board was replaced.
Source: Engadget, November 2023
From the field
“OpenAI is nothing without its people.”
Message posted by many OpenAI employees on X, November 2023 (source)
By the numbers
- 700+of about 770 OpenAI employees signed the letter to the board
- 2 hoursfor the first 500 signatures to come in
Level 5: World War

In a world war conflict, constructive language has almost disappeared. The goal at this level is to destroy the other side, even if everyone loses (lose-lose). No constructive outcome can be obtained at this level. The position taken is that winning is not enough and that others have to lose. The only option at this level is to separate team members so that they don’t hurt each other, because the conflict can turn hostile or even unsafe.
Signs
- Language is little or non-existent.
Response Options
- Unresolvable: Sometimes, when it gets to level 5, the conflict is unresolvable, and you need to figure out a way everyone can keep working without hurting each other.
Real-life example
The Dassler brothers split one company into Adidas and Puma
Adi and Rudolf Dassler made shoes together for more than 20 years. After a bitter falling out, they shut the family firm in 1948 and divided its factory and workers. Adi founded Adidas, Rudolf founded Puma, and their town of Herzogenaurach took sides for decades. No conversation could fix it. Separation was the only outcome, exactly what the model predicts at level 5.
Source: Wikipedia, Dassler brothers feud
From the field
“The relation to my brother was ideal from 1924 till 1933.”
Rudolf Dassler, quoted in Barbara Smit’s Sneaker Wars (source)
By the numbers
- 1948the year the brothers shut the shared company and split its staff
- 61 yearsuntil the two companies symbolically ended the feud with a football match in 2009
Source: The Local, September 2009
Conflict Level Diagnostic: Find Your Team’s Level
Not sure which level your project team is at? Answer six questions about what you see and hear, and the free Conflict Level Diagnostic tells you the most likely level, whether to step back or step in, and which response options fit. It opens with a sample conflict between developers and QA so you can see how it works.
- Name the conflict and say whether it is getting worse, stable or calming down.
- For each of the six questions, pick the answer closest to what you see in the team.
- Fill in the analyze and respond plan, then copy it or download it to share with your sponsor or HR.
Loading the Conflict Level Diagnostic… If it does not appear, please enable JavaScript.
Conflict Resolution

When conflict arises within their team, a project manager should have methods for conflict resolution ready. But it is also important for a project manager to know when to step back and when to step in. Agile team members can often navigate conflict on their own, even up to level 3. Take this opportunity to see if there is progress occurring. This lets your team grow and learn how to resolve conflicts themselves.
If, however, you decide that it is time to intervene, choose one of three response modes: analyze and respond, use structures, or reveal.
To spot trouble before it starts, review these 21 avoidable causes of conflict in project management.
Analyze and Respond

In analyze-and-respond mode, remember that you do not know the entire story. Consider that every perspective is valid and necessary for resolution. Each team member has their own perspective that should be considered.
Some questions to consider in this mode:
- What is the conflict level?
- What are the presented issues?
- In what way would I respond as side 1?
- In what way would I respond as side 2?
- Are there any open options for resolution?
- What should I do at this point?
Make a table of resolution options after you identify the conflict level, like the one below. Once the team is able to de-escalate, additional options become available for dealing with the conflict the next time it arises.
The 5 Conflict Levels at a Glance
Use this table to match what you hear in your project team to a level and a response.
| Level | What people want | Language you hear | Your response |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1Problem to Solve | Solve the problem together | “Here is what the test data shows.” | Step back. Collaboration or consensus. |
| 2Disagreement | Solve it, but protect themselves | “Some people feel the plan is unclear.” | Support the team and build safety. |
| 3Contest | Win the argument | “You never listen to what I say.” | Watch closely. Accommodate, negotiate or get factual. |
| 4Crusade | Protect their group, push others out | “It’s a matter of principle with them.” | Step in. Diplomacy and de-escalation. |
| 5World War | Make the other side lose | Little or nothing is said. | Separate people and escalate to HR. |
Based on Speed Leas’ levels of conflict, as adapted by Lyssa Adkins and Kristen Blake for PMI.
It is recommended that the resolution type you select for your team is one that leads to a win-win solution for all parties involved. This helps prevent continued conflict. An additional tool that is beneficial for project managers is understanding the organizational Conflict Model.
The Conflict Model, which describes how people think, feel, and act in the presence of conflict, helps managers learn to navigate conflict resolution effectively for their team and for organizational conflicts.
Conflict Levels Quiz: Test Yourself
Ten quick questions to check that you can recognize each conflict level. Pick your answer, then open the toggle to see if you were right.
Can You Spot the Conflict Level?
10 questions. Count your correct answers: 9 or 10 means you are ready to coach your team through conflict.
A teammate says, “You never listen when I raise testing concerns.” Which level does this language most likely signal?
- ALevel 1: Problem to Solve
- BLevel 3: Contest
- CLevel 5: World War
- DLevel 2: Disagreement
Show answer
Answer B: Level 3: Contest. “Never” and “always” are overgeneralizations, a classic sign of level 3, where the aim is to win.
At which level does protecting yourself become as important as solving the problem?
- ALevel 1: Problem to Solve
- BLevel 4: Crusade
- CLevel 2: Disagreement
- DLevel 5: World War
Show answer
Answer C: Level 2: Disagreement. At level 2, people are wary rather than hostile. They guard their words and hold some information back.
Two developers debate two database designs using benchmark data and agree to test both. Which level is this?
- ALevel 1: Problem to Solve
- BLevel 2: Disagreement
- CLevel 3: Contest
- DLevel 4: Crusade
Show answer
Answer A: Level 1: Problem to Solve. They share information, use facts and want the same outcome. That is healthy level 1 conflict.
What is the main aim of the people involved at level 5?
- AWin the argument
- BReach a compromise
- CProtect their own group
- DMake the other side lose, even if everyone loses
Show answer
Answer D: Make the other side lose, even if everyone loses. Level 5 is lose-lose. Winning is not enough; the other side has to lose.
Who originally created the five levels of conflict model?
- ASpeed Leas
- BLyssa Adkins
- CKenneth Thomas
- DPatrick Lencioni
Show answer
Answer A: Speed Leas. Speed Leas described the levels in 1985 for church conflict. Lyssa Adkins later adapted them for agile teams.
Which response is recommended at level 4, Crusade?
- AConsensus
- BDiplomacy: facilitate between the groups
- CDo nothing and wait
- DCollaboration games
Show answer
Answer B: Diplomacy: facilitate between the groups. Direct communication has broken down, so the project manager acts as a facilitator between the groups.
According to Lyssa Adkins, agile teams can often navigate conflict on their own up to which level?
- ALevel 1
- BLevel 2
- CLevel 3
- DLevel 5
Show answer
Answer C: Level 3. Adkins advises coaches to wait and watch, because teams can often handle conflict even in the level 3 range.
Factions are entrenched, and people are attacked for which side they are on, not for their ideas. Which level is this?
- ALevel 2: Disagreement
- BLevel 3: Contest
- CLevel 1: Problem to Solve
- DLevel 4: Crusade
Show answer
Answer D: Level 4: Crusade. Attacks on affiliation rather than ideas, and a righteous attitude, mark level 4.
At level 3, which response fits when the issue can be divided between the parties?
- ANegotiate
- BSeparate the parties
- CConsensus
- DIgnore it
Show answer
Answer A: Negotiate. If an issue is dividable, negotiation can work at level 3.
In analyze-and-respond mode, what should the project manager assume?
- AOne side is clearly right
- BYou do not know the whole story, and every perspective is valid
- CYou must step in at once
- DOnly the facts matter, not feelings
Show answer
Answer B: You do not know the whole story, and every perspective is valid. Analyze and respond starts from the idea that the entire story is unknown and each perspective matters.
Video: Navigating the 5 Levels of Conflict
This short talk walks through Speed Leas’ five levels of conflict as described in Lyssa Adkins’ book Coaching Agile Teams, and shows how a Scrum Master or project manager can help a team de-escalate.
Scrum Master as a Conflict Navigator
Agile State of Mind explains the five levels of conflict and how to guide team members back to level 1 (11 minutes).
Video by Agile State of Mind on YouTube.
Conflict Level Facts Worth Checking
10 Conflict Claims, Checked
Common claims about workplace conflict and the conflict levels, checked against the original sources.
| Claim | Verdict | What the data says |
|---|---|---|
| Speed Leas created the five levels of conflict for agile software teams. | False | Leas described the levels in 1985 in a book on church conflict. Lyssa Adkins adapted the model for agile teams in 2009. PMI |
| A conflict always climbs through the levels in order. | False | Leas himself notes that groups do not move neatly from level to level and sometimes skip levels on the way up or down. Christianity Today |
| Employees spend about 2.8 hours a week dealing with conflict. | Out of date | That was the 2008 U.S. figure. A 2022 study found 4.34 hours a week. Myers-Briggs, 2022 |
| Workplace conflict costs U.S. companies $359 billion a year. | Partly true | The figure is an estimate of paid hours spent on conflict in 2008, not a measured annual cost today. CPP, 2008 |
| All conflict is bad for a project. | False | Level 1 conflict is healthy. 81% of U.S. workers have seen positive outcomes from conflict, such as better solutions. CPP, 2008 |
| A project manager should step in at the first sign of conflict. | False | Adkins advises watching first, because agile teams can often settle conflict up to level 3 on their own. DZone excerpt, Coaching Agile Teams |
| A level 5 conflict can always be fixed with a good mediator. | False | At level 5, the model sees no hope of a constructive outcome. The priority is separating people so no one gets hurt. PMI |
| Poor communication is the top cause of workplace conflict. | True | Respondents named poor communication as the number one cause, ahead of role clarity and workload. Myers-Briggs, 2022 |
| Most people expect HR to sort out workplace conflict. | False | Only 8% said HR is responsible. Most named line managers (45%) or everyone (42%). SBAM, on Myers-Briggs 2022 |
| Workplace conflict is becoming less common. | False | 36% now deal with conflict often, very often or all the time, up from 29% in 2008. SBAM, on Myers-Briggs 2022 |
Checked November 2026.
Conflict Levels FAQ
Conflict Levels: Common Questions
What are the 5 levels of conflict?
The five levels are Problem to Solve, Disagreement, Contest, Crusade and World War. Each level is more intense than the last, moving from a shared problem at level 1 to a lose-lose fight at level 5.
Who created the five levels of conflict model?
Speed Leas, a conflict consultant with the Alban Institute, described the five levels in 1985 for conflict in churches. Agile coach Lyssa Adkins adapted the model for agile project teams, which is why it appears in many PMI-ACP study guides.
How can a project manager tell which conflict level a team is at?
Listen to the language. Specific, factual talk points to level 1. Vague, guarded talk points to level 2. “Always”, “never” and blame point to level 3. Talk about principles and sides points to level 4. Little or no talk points to level 5.
When should a project manager step in?
At levels 1 and 2, step back and support the team. At level 3, give the team a short chance to de-escalate, then step in with facts if it does not. At level 4, act as a facilitator between the groups. At level 5, separate the people involved and escalate to HR or senior management.
Can a conflict go back down a level?
Yes. The goal at every level is to de-escalate, ideally back to level 1. Teams that know the model can often notice when they are drifting into a contest and pull themselves back.
What is the difference between level 3 and level 4?
At level 3 (Contest), people want to win the argument, and sides are forming. At level 4 (Crusade), sides have hardened into factions, people are attacked for the group they belong to, and some believe the only solution is for the other side to leave.
Suggested articles:
- Task Conflict vs. Relationship Conflict
- How to Get Your First IT Job: A Step-by-Step Guide
- 4 Types of Organizational Conflict (Levels)
Shane Drumm, holding certifications in PMP®, PMI-ACP®, CSM, and LPM, is the author behind numerous articles featured here. Hailing from County Cork, Ireland, his expertise lies in implementing Agile methodologies with geographically dispersed teams for software development projects. In his leisure, he dedicates time to web development and Ironman triathlon training. Find out more about Shane on shanedrumm.com and please reach out and connect with Shane on LinkedIn.